CSA Week 7: Cucumber Tea Sandwiches

Cucumber Tea Sandwiches

When we first started getting cucumbers in our CSA box, I thought maybe I could ignore them. I have never really liked cucumbers (am I the only one who thinks they taste odd and somewhat bitter?), and I can count on one hand the number of times I have bought one on purpose.

But ignoring them turned out to be a terrible strategy…they just kept multiplying. Each week for the last four weeks, the CSA box has been incredibly heavy…full of pounds and pounds of cucumbers!

I tried giving them away. But seriously, how many people are suffering from a shortage of enormous cucumbers? That barely made a dent.

So, it’s time to get serious! My friend Sarah (who, bless her, did take a cucumber off my hands) suggested tea sandwiches. She made the first round herself, to convince me. And I must admit, they weren’t half bad! I loved the way the sharp, fresh chives accented the cucumbers and brought a little life to this old classic.

Okay, honestly, this could not be easier to make! Tea sandwiches are a great addition to, well…tea time… But they are also a good, quick dish to make for picnics and potlucks! Or even lunch (though you might skip cutting them into cute little baby sandwiches if you are just eating one for lunch).

Thinly SlicedStart by very thinly slicing one large cucumber (okay, I did two…because I was so excited about getting rid of the cucumbers). If you have a mandoline, now is a great time to break it out! Ideally, all the slices will be quite thin and even…I don’t have a mandoline, which also meant it took about 5 minutes longer to get the cucumber ready.

AssemblyNow all you need to do is very thinly spread cream cheese on each slice of bread. I used white wheat bread, which is somewhat healthier and (I think) tastes better than most white breads, and about 1½–2 tsp. cream cheese per slice.

To make this easier on yourself, go ahead and use a flavored cream cheese! I grabbed a tub of chive cream cheese from the grocery store (chive and onion would also have been great) to save time. But if you prefer to go old school, mix about 1 tbsp. chopped chives into ½ cup softened cream cheese.

Now layer the cucumbers onto the bread. I put them on about 2 or 3 thick, depending on how fat they were and how easy it was to layer them.

Proper TrimSo. I hope your bread is more evenly shaped than mine was! Cut off the exterior crusts so that you have a slightly smaller square. Cut that square into four little squares.

Stack of Tea SandwichesAnd you’re done!

Be aware that the amounts below might vary somewhat based on how thinly you slice your cucumbers and how thick you spread your cream cheese. Honestly, I am somewhat hesitant to even call this a recipe, because it’s more like a plan than a specific procedure. But here you go! Happy cucumber-eating!

Cucumber Tea Sandwiches

makes 24 tea sandwiches

1 large cucumber
12 slices white wheat sandwich bread
½ cup chive cream cheese

Trim the ends off and very thinly slice the cucumber into rounds.
Spread about 2 tsp. cream cheese evenly on each slice of bread. Layer half the bread slices with 8–10 thin cucumber slices. Top with remaining bread.
Using a serrated knife, gently slice off the outer crusts of the bread (slice straight across the top, even if this cuts off some of the white bread). Cut the crustless sandwiches into square quarters.


  1. One year ago: White Bean Salad
  2. Two years ago: Tomato-Almond Pesto

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.